PICOT/Evidence Appraisal Assignment

Rubric

NR439_PICOT_Worksheet
NR439_PICOT_Worksheet
Criteria Ratings Pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomePICOT question

Question or nursing problem is identified and is an independent nursing decision.

50.0 pts

Outstanding Question or nursing problem identified that is an independent nursing decision

44.0 pts

Very good Question or nursing problem is identified that is an independent nursing decision

40.0 pts

Competent Question or nursing problem is identified that is an independent nursing decision.

19.0 pts

Question or nursing problem is identified but is not an independent nursing decision.

0.0 pts

PICOT question missing.
50.0 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomePICOT elements

PICOT elements are correctly identified. Outcomes are measurable.

50.0 pts

PICOT elements are correctly identified. Outcomes are measurable.

44.0 pts

One PICOT element is not correctly identified. Outcomes are measurable. PICOT/Evidence Appraisal Assignment

40.0 pts

Two PICOT elements are not correctly identified. Outcomes are not measurable

19.0 pts

Three or more PICOT elements are not correctly identified. Outcomes are not measurable.

0.0 pts

PICOT elements are missing.
50.0 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomePractice issue and scope of the problem

Practice issue/problem is thoroughly described. The need for change is evident. Practice area is identified. Identification of the practice issue is clear. Scope of the problem is identified.

50.0 pts

Practice issue/problem is thoroughly described. The need for change is evident. Practice area is identified. Identification of the practice issue is clear. Scope of the problem is identified.

44.0 pts

Practice issue/problem is partially described. The need for change is evident. Practice area is identified. Identification of the practice issue is clear. Scope of the problem is identified.

40.0 pts

Practice issue/problem is vaguely described. The need for change is not obvious. Practice area is identified. Identification of the practice issue is clear. Scope of the problem is identified.

19.0 pts

Practice issue/problem is vaguely described. The need for change is not obvious. Practice area is not identified. Identification of the practice issue is not clear. Scope of the problem is not identified

0.0 pts

Not answered.
 PICOT/Evidence Appraisal Assignment
PICOT/Evidence Appraisal Assignment
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeEvidence

Appropriately identifies the types of evidences that should be gathered.

20.0 pts

Identifies and documents four types of evidence needed for review.

17.0 pts

Identifies and documents three types of evidence needed for review.

16.0 pts

Identifies and documents two types of evidence needed for review

7.0 pts

Identifies and documents one type of evidence needed for review.

0.0 pts

Does not document types of evidence.
20.0 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeRationale for Evidence

Gives rationale for the types of evidence that is gathered.

20.0 pts

Thoroughly describes rationale for checked types of evidence.

17.0 pts

Good description of rationale for checked types of evidence.

16.0 pts

Partial description of rationale for checked types of evidence.

7.0 pts

Minimal rationale for checked types of evidence.

0.0 pts

Rationale missing.
20.0 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSearch Terms

Describes search terms that are manageable and will yield good results.

5.0 pts

Thoroughly describes manageable search terms.

4.0 pts

Good description of manageable search terms.

3.0 pts

Partially describes manageable search terms.

2.0 pts

Minimally describes manageable search terms.

0.0 pts

Search terms are absent.
5.0 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeHow to Narrow Search in the Library

Provides a description of how the library search will be narrowed to produce relevant returns.
PICOT/Evidence Appraisal Assignment

5.0 pts

Thoroughly describes how to narrow searchFull Marks

4.0 pts

Good description how to narrow search.

3.0 pts

Partially describes how to narrow search.

2.0 pts

Minimally describes how to narrow search.

0.0 pts

No description given.
5.0 pts
Total Points: 200.0. PICOT/Evidence Appraisal Assignment